21539 0 false 2009-06-18T19:25:58+01:00 55784 1634 691 very-strange-bug-on-form-submit-under-ie7 699 2706 open 1.2.2 form hidden input 2009-06-22T21:04:59+01:00 55784 grazius grazius Christoph Pojer http://mootools.lighthouseapp.com/projects/2706/tickets/691 2.0 Hi, i've got a very strange bug under IE7. if u make a form with an hidden input with the id = 'action' the form could not be submited ... javascript error ! 'action' is not a reserved word ? @@@ <script type="text/javascript"> //<![CDATA[ window.addEvent("domready", function(){ //send form $('myForm').addEvent('submit',function(event){ // block event.stop(); // submit return this.set('send', { onComplete: function(response) { alert('ok'); } }); // send the form alert('send binded'); //Send the form. this.send(); alert('form sended'); }); }); //]]> </script> <form id="myForm" name="myForm" method="post" action="myaction.php" enctype="multipart/form-data"> <input id="action" name="action" value="myaction" type="hidden" /> <input id="visiblefield" name="visiblefield" value="value2" type="text" /> <input id="bt" type="image" value="test" /> </form> @@@ Hi, i've got a very strange bug under IE7. if u make a form with an hidden input with the id = 'action' the form could not be submited ... javascript error ! 'action' is not a reserved word ? @@@ <script type="text/javascript"> //<![CDATA[ window.addEvent("domready", function(){ //send form $('myForm').addEvent('submit',function(event){ // block event.stop(); // submit return this.set('send', { onComplete: function(response) { alert('ok'); } }); // send the form alert('send binded'); //Send the form. this.send(); alert('form sended'); }); }); //]]> </script> <form id="myForm" name="myForm" method="post" action="myaction.php" enctype="multipart/form-data"> <input id="action" name="action" value="myaction" type="hidden" /> <input id="visiblefield" name="visiblefield" value="value2" type="text" /> <input id="bt" type="image" value="test" /> </form> @@@ <div><p>Hi, i've got a very strange bug under IE7. if u make a form with an hidden input with the id = 'action' the form could not be submited ... javascript error !</p> <p>'action' is not a reserved word ?</p> <pre><code> &lt;script type=&quot;text/javascript&quot;&gt; //&lt;![CDATA[ window.addEvent(&quot;domready&quot;, function(){ //send form $('myForm').addEvent('submit',function(event){ // block event.stop(); // submit return this.set('send', { onComplete: function(response) { alert('ok'); } }); // send the form alert('send binded'); //Send the form. this.send(); alert('form sended'); }); }); //]]&gt; &lt;/script&gt; &lt;form id=&quot;myForm&quot; name=&quot;myForm&quot; method=&quot;post&quot; action=&quot;myaction.php&quot; enctype=&quot;multipart/form-data&quot;&gt; &lt;input id=&quot;action&quot; name=&quot;action&quot; value=&quot;myaction&quot; type=&quot;hidden&quot; /&gt; &lt;input id=&quot;visiblefield&quot; name=&quot;visiblefield&quot; value=&quot;value2&quot; type=&quot;text&quot; /&gt; &lt;input id=&quot;bt&quot; type=&quot;image&quot; value=&quot;test&quot; /&gt; &lt;/form&gt; </code></pre></div> 0 Hi, i've got a very strange bug under IE7. if u make a form with an hidden input with the id = 'action' the form could not be submited ... javascript error ! 'action' is not a reserved word ? @@@ <script type="text/javascript"> //<![CDATA[ window.addEvent("domready", function(){ //send form $('myForm').addEvent('submit',function(event){ // block event.stop(); // submit return this.set('send', { onComplete: function(response) { alert('ok'); } }); // send the form alert('send binded'); //Send the form. this.send(); alert('form sended'); }); }); //]]> </script> <form id="myForm" name="myForm" method="post" action="myaction.php" enctype="multipart/form-data"> <input id="action" name="action" value="myaction" type="hidden" /> <input id="visiblefield" name="visiblefield" value="value2" type="text" /> <input id="bt" type="image" value="test" /> </form> @@@ <div><p>Hi,<br> i've got a very strange bug under IE7.<br> if u make a form with an hidden input with the id = 'action' the form could not be submited ... javascript error !</p> <p>'action' is not a reserved word ?</p> <pre> <code> &lt;script type="text/javascript"&gt; //&lt;![CDATA[ window.addEvent("domready", function(){ //send form $('myForm').addEvent('submit',function(event){ // block event.stop(); // submit return this.set('send', { onComplete: function(response) { alert('ok'); } }); // send the form alert('send binded'); //Send the form. this.send(); alert('form sended'); }); }); //]]&gt; &lt;/script&gt; &lt;form id="myForm" name="myForm" method="post" action="myaction.php" enctype="multipart/form-data"&gt; &lt;input id="action" name="action" value="myaction" type="hidden" /&gt; &lt;input id="visiblefield" name="visiblefield" value="value2" type="text" /&gt; &lt;input id="bt" type="image" value="test" /&gt; &lt;/form&gt;</code> </pre></div> false 2009-06-18T19:25:58+01:00 55784 --- {} 1634 691 very-strange-bug-on-form-submit-under-ie7 0 2706 new 1.2.2 form hidden input 2009-06-18T19:26:00+01:00 55784 grazius grazius http://mootools.lighthouseapp.com/projects/2706/tickets/691 2.0 0 same effect if u remove enctype="multipart/form-data" <div><p>same effect if u remove enctype="multipart/form-data"</p></div> false 2009-06-18T19:27:23+01:00 55784 --- {} 1634 691 very-strange-bug-on-form-submit-under-ie7 0 2706 new 1.2.2 form hidden input 2009-06-18T19:27:24+01:00 55784 grazius grazius http://mootools.lighthouseapp.com/projects/2706/tickets/691 2.0 0 More worrying ! if u put this after the form.send(), action property 'action' is null !!! @@@ // send the form alert(this.getProperty('action')); @@@ <div><p>More worrying !</p> <p>if u put this after the form.send(), action property 'action' is null !!!</p> <pre> <code>// send the form alert(this.getProperty('action'));</code> </pre></div> false 2009-06-19T09:06:35+01:00 55784 --- {} 1634 691 very-strange-bug-on-form-submit-under-ie7 0 2706 new 1.2.2 form hidden input 2009-06-19T09:06:38+01:00 55784 grazius grazius http://mootools.lighthouseapp.com/projects/2706/tickets/691 2.0 0 ... hummmm put it before the send not after <div><p>... hummmm put it before the send not after</p></div> false 2009-06-19T09:07:31+01:00 55784 --- {} 1634 691 very-strange-bug-on-form-submit-under-ie7 0 2706 new 1.2.2 form hidden input 2009-06-19T09:07:36+01:00 55784 grazius grazius http://mootools.lighthouseapp.com/projects/2706/tickets/691 2.0 21539 0 An input with name 'action' is not ok since ie will overwrite existing action property from the form. i mean $('form-id').action normaly returns the action attribute from the form, but in your case it will return the input with name 'action', because ie works like this. Try use another name to avoid this problem. In fact there is a way to fix this and ill try to send the patch when i got time. This can be set to hold. <div><p>An input with name 'action' is not ok since ie will overwrite existing action property from the form.</p> <p>i mean $('form-id').action normaly returns the action attribute from the form, but in your case it will return the input with name 'action', because ie works like this. Try use another name to avoid this problem.</p> <p>In fact there is a way to fix this and ill try to send the patch when i got time.<br> This can be set to hold.</p></div> false 2009-06-19T13:02:33+01:00 55784 --- :assigned_user: 1634 691 very-strange-bug-on-form-submit-under-ie7 0 2706 new 1.2.2 form hidden input 2009-06-19T13:02:38+01:00 30920 Fábio M. Costa grazius Christoph Pojer http://mootools.lighthouseapp.com/projects/2706/tickets/691 2.0 21539 0 Thanks for the response. I work actually on integration of mocha-ui on differents system : php (extra work) : On "oscommerce" manager and all 'action' are passed in hidden field name 'action'. java (real job) : It's the same think but on a very big application. For my extra work i can wait but for my real job this problem have a real cost (in money). It's an IE bug or a Mootools bug (for IE) ? <div><p>Thanks for the response.</p> <p>I work actually on integration of mocha-ui on differents system :</p> <p>php (extra work) : On "oscommerce" manager and all 'action' are passed in hidden field name 'action'.<br> java (real job) : It's the same think but on a very big application.</p> <p>For my extra work i can wait but for my real job this problem have a real cost (in money).</p> <p>It's an IE bug or a Mootools bug (for IE) ?</p></div> false 2009-06-19T14:26:52+01:00 55784 --- {} 1634 691 very-strange-bug-on-form-submit-under-ie7 0 2706 new 1.2.2 form hidden input 2009-06-19T14:26:57+01:00 55784 grazius grazius Christoph Pojer http://mootools.lighthouseapp.com/projects/2706/tickets/691 2.0 21539 0 This is a known bug in Internet Explorer, therefor we cannot fix it :( The solution is not to use fields with a name like "action", "method" or other properties. <div><p>This is a known bug in Internet Explorer, therefor we cannot fix it :( The solution is not to use fields with a name like "action", "method" or other properties.</p></div> true 2009-06-19T18:43:37+01:00 55784 --- :state: new 1634 691 very-strange-bug-on-form-submit-under-ie7 0 2706 invalid 1.2.2 form hidden input 2009-06-19T18:43:42+01:00 21539 Christoph Pojer grazius Christoph Pojer http://mootools.lighthouseapp.com/projects/2706/tickets/691 2.0 21539 0 No!! Zilence in fact this can be fixed. It is a IE bug but can be fixed. @@@ javascript Element.Properties.send = { set: function(options){ var send = this.retrieve('send'); if (send) send.cancel(); return this.eliminate('send').store('send:options', $extend({ data: this, link: 'cancel', method: this.get('method') || 'post', url: this.getAttributeNode('action').nodeValue }, options)); }, @@@ The difference now is that instead of using this.get('action') you should use: @@@ javascript this.getAttributeNode('action').nodeValue @@@ I dont know if its better to use this fix on the getProperty function or directly on the send property. This works crossbrowser. Please set as open!! (or another better state) <div><p>No!!</p> <p>Zilence in fact this can be fixed. It is a IE bug but can be fixed.</p> <pre> <code class="javascript">Element.Properties.send = { set: function(options){ var send = this.retrieve('send'); if (send) send.cancel(); return this.eliminate('send').store('send:options', $extend({ data: this, link: 'cancel', method: this.get('method') || 'post', url: this.getAttributeNode('action').nodeValue }, options)); },</code> </pre> <p>The difference now is that instead of using this.get('action') you should use:</p> <pre> <code class= "javascript">this.getAttributeNode('action').nodeValue</code> </pre> <p>I dont know if its better to use this fix on the getProperty function or directly on the send property.</p> <p>This works crossbrowser. Please set as open!! (or another better state)</p></div> true 2009-06-20T03:45:08+01:00 55784 --- {} 1634 691 very-strange-bug-on-form-submit-under-ie7 0 2706 invalid 1.2.2 form hidden input 2009-06-20T03:45:13+01:00 30920 Fábio M. Costa grazius Christoph Pojer http://mootools.lighthouseapp.com/projects/2706/tickets/691 2.0 21539 0 That is very interesting. We are going to consider it for inclusion in MooTools 2.0 <div><p>That is very interesting. We are going to consider it for inclusion in MooTools 2.0</p></div> true 2009-06-20T09:16:30+01:00 55784 --- {} 1634 691 very-strange-bug-on-form-submit-under-ie7 0 2706 invalid 1.2.2 form hidden input 2009-06-20T09:16:34+01:00 21539 Christoph Pojer grazius Christoph Pojer http://mootools.lighthouseapp.com/projects/2706/tickets/691 2.0 21539 0 false 2009-06-21T19:14:55+01:00 55784 --- :state: invalid 1634 691 very-strange-bug-on-form-submit-under-ie7 0 2706 open 1.2.2 form hidden input 2009-06-21T19:14:57+01:00 28080 Sebastian Markbåge grazius Christoph Pojer http://mootools.lighthouseapp.com/projects/2706/tickets/691 2.0 21539 0 Thanks that work fine now under IE. <div><p>Thanks that work fine now under IE.</p></div> false 2009-06-22T21:04:57+01:00 55784 --- {} 1634 691 very-strange-bug-on-form-submit-under-ie7 0 2706 open 1.2.2 form hidden input 2009-06-22T21:04:59+01:00 55784 grazius grazius Christoph Pojer http://mootools.lighthouseapp.com/projects/2706/tickets/691 2.0